Position · 02
Carvana (CVNA)
Speculative growth long, February 2024
+550.1%
Total gain if held to the 11/04/2026 close
Stock price at analysis
$11.93
02/15/2024, split-adjusted
Forecast price
$59.40
Retake of previous highs; timeframe undetermined
Current price
$77.56
11/04/2026 close
- Date
- February 2024
- Position
- Growth / Turnaround
- Price at analysis
- $11.93 (February 2024 entry, per chart; split-adjusted basis, see note below)
- Forecast
- Retake previous highs in turnaround growth play
- Exit price
- N/A
- Current price
- $77.56 (11/04/2026 close)
Thesis
Carvana’s pricing strategy followed the market to hold inventory, and it failed when post-COVID used-vehicle prices reverted, raising inventory costs while idle locations ran at a recurring loss. Facing insolvency, management completed an out-of-court debt restructuring that deferred about $2B of near-term interest, partnered with a consumer debt servicer on integrated financing, and consolidated 38 underperforming sites, restoring profitability. Transparent online pricing and financing, and the vending-machine delivery, made the value proposition clear. If growth and margins held, a retake of the previous highs ($59.40 post-split) was expected, with an undetermined timeframe.
Total gain = current ÷ analysis price − 1. Annualized = (1 + total)^(365 ÷ days) − 1. Price return only; dividends excluded.
Position Performance
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Analysis price | $11.93 (split-adjusted basis, per chart) |
| Forecast: previous highs | $59.40 post-split, timeframe undetermined: +397.9% |
| Forecast: chart target | $86.13 (chart label +721.96%; price-based +622.0%) |
| Stop (chart) | $7.54 (−63.2%) |
| Risk/reward (chart) | 11.42 |
| If held (current price) | $77.56 (11/04/2026) |
| Days held | 993 |
| Total gain | +550.1% |
| Annualized gain | +99.0% |